Boundary paradoxes: the social life of transparency and accountability activism in Delhi (2024)

Related Papers

Food Fight: Civil Society Innovation and Resilience in the Struggle for the Right to Food in India

Peter Houtzager

India's national network of social justice activists and civil society organisations helped achieve legal recognition for the Right to Food in the early 2000's and are engaged in an ongoing struggle to implement the right to food in practice. The legal strategy of the Right to Food Campaign, and the shortcomings of India's primary right to food vehicle, the Public Distribution System (PDS) are well documented. There is relatively little on the Campaign's contribution to innovation and improvement in the PDS, and its role in blocking a rollback of both the Right to Food and the PDS. After a decade, following the trajectory of the RTF campaign and the activism to implement PDS effectively, we believe that the composition of the national activist network and, related, its multi-scalar strategy, have been vital to its ability to shape national political debate and government policy in a first period (2001-08), and subsequently to defend advances in reform of the Right to Food from rollback in a subsequent openly hostile political environment (2009-2015). Based on new research carried out in 2015 we explain what happens to a network when one of its members enters electoral politics, and the campaign's resilience in a hostile political environment. In this paper we combine social network analysis, informant interviews, participant observation, and archival research to identify the formation of ties between individuals that connect diverse activist networks, and how, in different political environments these networks first helped generate new ideas and practices for the Right to Food, and then defended those from reversal.

View PDF

Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute

Seeking signs of transparency: audit, materiality, and monuments to active citizenship in New Delhi

2019 •

Martin Webb

View PDF

PoLAR: Political and Legal Anthropology Review

State Transparency after the Neoliberal Turn: The Politics, Limits, and Paradoxes of India's Right to Information Law

2013 •

Aradhana Sharma

View PDF

Seminar: The Monthly Symposium

Incorporating People's Will in Governance

2022 •

Vidya Venkat

In this paper, I discuss the formative phase of the right to information movement in India to demonstrate how the framing of the Right to Information Act was an expression of "people's will". I use archival research here to demonstrate the manner in which civil society organisations contributed to the drafting of the law.

View PDF

Journal of Democracy

Civil Society Versus Corruption

2007 •

Rob Jenkins

View PDF

American Ethnologist

The righteous and the rightful: The technomoral politics of NGOs, social movements, and the state in India

2016 •

Aradhana Sharma

View PDF

The righteous and the rightful

Erica Bornstein, Aradhana Sharma

Civil society groups today are honored and relied on by governments, as well as tightly regulated and scrutinized for challenging state policies and agencies. In contemporary India, political dynamics of collaboration and confrontation between state and nonstate actors increasingly unfold in legal-social fields, taking “technomoral” forms. Mixing technocratic languages of law and policy with moral pronouncements, these actors assert themselves as virtuous agents, marking their political legitimacy as keepers of the public interest. Using ethnographic research with Indian NGOs, social movements, and a political party, we show that as civil society groups interact with state bodies, they redefine institutional boundaries and claim moral authority over public stewardship. Technomoral strategies are neither depoliticized nor antipolitical, but constitute a righteous and rightful form of politics. [NGOs, state, India, morality, activist politics, neoliberalism, law]

View PDF

Economic and Political Weekly

EPW essay_Reclaiming the Republic.pdf

2019 •

Vidya Venkat

On the occasion of India’s 70th Republic Day, it is worth considering how the very foundational idea of a republic, in which supreme power is held by the people, is at risk despite free and fair elections. To arrive at that argument, this article delineates the historical trajectory of India’s Right to Information movement as arising out of the need to address the unfinished agenda of democratisation since independence. It then discusses how the movement has strengthened oppositional politics by expanding the terrain for political participation and has also empowered individual citizens in their struggles to claim their entitlements from the state. By resisting scrutiny under the Right to Information Act and attempting to dilute the law’s empowering potential, political representatives and bureaucrats are subverting democracy itself.

View PDF

Citizen Action and National Policy, John Gaventa and Rosemary McGee (eds)

Is Knowledge Power?: The Right to Information Campaign in India

2009 •

Amita Baviskar

View PDF


Freedom of information lessons from India: Collaboration, co-production and rights-based agenda building

2018 •

Rajdeep Pakanati

View PDF
Boundary paradoxes: the social life of transparency and accountability activism in Delhi (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Lakeisha Bayer VM

Last Updated:

Views: 5603

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Lakeisha Bayer VM

Birthday: 1997-10-17

Address: Suite 835 34136 Adrian Mountains, Floydton, UT 81036

Phone: +3571527672278

Job: Manufacturing Agent

Hobby: Skimboarding, Photography, Roller skating, Knife making, Paintball, Embroidery, Gunsmithing

Introduction: My name is Lakeisha Bayer VM, I am a brainy, kind, enchanting, healthy, lovely, clean, witty person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.